The League of Women Voters of Manatee County Education Issues Committee observes the Manatee County School Board meetings for items of interest to citizens and the League and notes adherence, or lack of adherence, to good governance procedures and the sunshine laws. The following are the major points from the school board meeting on 11/10/2026
The meeting was called to order at 5:30 p.m. by Chair Spray followed by the reading of the Purpose Statement by Mr. Choate. The invocation was given by Jerry Parrish, Outreach Director of The Forge. The Manatee High School Color Guard presented the colors.
Student Celebrations/Recognitions – Associate Superintendent Kevin Chapman facilitated the recognitions.
Presentation by Former Air Force Captain Terry Gruters.
Mr. Tatem made the introduction. Captain Gruters recounted his career as an Air Force pilot that resulted in his actions freeing his brother who was held as a prisoner of war in Vietnam. Both Captain Gruters and his older brother attended the Air Force Academy. Captain Gruters’ brother was shot down, miraculously rescued, recuperated and returned to Vietnam. He was again shot down but no one knew for a long time if he was captured or killed. After graduating Terry was sent to Vietnam with the hope of helping his brother. His first mission was as a spotter in low flying planes to find targets. When the plane engine quit, they were able to land and were rescued by helicopter. Terry then learned his brother was a POW. His next training resulted in an assignment co-piloting a B52 bomber with a mission to hit missiles defending the capital, Hanoi. The successful mission ended with losing engines and parachuting over the Thailand jungle. Four days later Hanoi was unprotected, POWs released, and his brother came home after 5 years and 4 months in captivity. Both brothers came home safely. Capt. Gruters presented the audience, including several Manatee High School JROTC cadets, with CD’s that shared his story.
Farm City Week Celebration and Proclamation.
Bernie's Book Bank Title 1 Program Recognition.
Todd Wyman, Chairman of Florida Suncoast chapter for Bernie’s Book Bank, along with Amy Bott, Executive Director, and Andrea Doggett, Partnership Manager, showcased their partnership program with the district. Noting low reading proficiency and few books in some homes, their mission is to provide free high-quality books to build home libraries. This year they have distributed 8,300 books to 2,000 kindergarten and pre-kindergarten students in Manatee and Sarasota Counties. Next year the goal is to quadruple impact with 34,000 books going to 8,500 students. Yesterday books were distributed at Bashaw Elementary with the Superintendent and some Board Members attending. Ms. Bott said research shows significant learning gains from getting Bernie Books. Mr. Choate said, it was “so fun to see the kids; how happy they were to get the book and to write their name in their book.”
Public Comments
JO, parent of an ESE student, expressed her concern for the safety and care of disabled students, saying that teachers are spread incredibly thin. She cited lack of accommodations that work, limitations of public schools, too many students in classes to address student needs with parents volunteering in classrooms. She said, “It is unfair for expecting teachers to perform miracles without the support they need” and she is “tired of ESE students getting the crumbs of what is left.” She expressed concern about the passage of Amendment 3 on ESE teachers.
SG reminded them he was there on October 6 and talked about bleacher running. He described a girl on a track team, who had won state awards, having to run 4 sets of bleachers at the same time football players were running the bleachers. A large boy slipped and fell into them and they all fell; the girl was injured and parents sued. He requested the practice of bleacher running be ended.
SZ spoke on behalf the Manatee Charter Schools Consortium and thanked Ms. Spray and Mr. Tatem for visiting their schools and listening to them about a fair share of tax. He noted that Dr. Valerie Hyer’s retirement is on the consent agenda and wanted to recognize her dedicated guidance for charter schools through changing regulations and sometimes confusing and difficult processes. He noted that she has made a lasting difference in children’s lives and her unwavering dedication to public education. He thanked her for her service and wished her well in her retirement.
Consent Items. 17 items were approved 5-0.
New Business (Non-Consent Items)
Approval of the Budget Amendments for September 2026 (No Financial Impact). Approved 5-0 with no discussion.
Approval of the District's School Internal Accounts Audit Report as of and for the Fiscal
Year Ended June 30, 2026 (No Financial Impact).
Ms. Sellers described there were no findings, misstatements, or disagreements. It was a clean audit of the schools’ internal accounts. Mr. Kennedy noted that there are $7.5 million dollars held in internal accounts across the school district. While he was not suggesting any changes to policies or procedures, he wanted to flag that for thought. Ms. Spray commented that millage funds have reduced costs for what parents are responsible for when their children are involved in activities. Carrying over this amount is a lot while charging students for buses for events. She noted there are burdens placed on students and parents to participate in activities. Approved 5-0.
Approval of the Revision of the Job Description and Position of Business Process Analyst to Analyst, Benefits and Compliance (No Financial Impact). Approved 5-0 with no discussion.
New Business (No Superintendent Recommendation)
Approval of Proposed Revisions to the Citizen Financial Audit Committee Charter. Mr. Kennedy thanked Ms. Sellers and her team for their help with CFAC and briefed Board Members on a recent meeting. He noted that Mr. Daniels will be at the December meeting. Mr. Choate agreed there has to be oversight on referendum money but there was a need to change how it functioned. Ms. Spray commented that millage is tracked over several programs and hopes Mr. Daniels will have recommendations for ease of tracking. Approved 5-0.
Acceptance of Annual Evaluation of School Board Attorney (No Financial Impact). Mr. Tatem thanked Mr. Dye for his dedication, honesty, and correct legal advice. Ms. Spray thanked Mr. Dye for helping to acclimate her to her role and also while in it. Mr. Kennedy thanked Mr. Dye for picking up the slack when general counsel left the district. Ms. Felton said, “ditto.” Approved 5-0.
Approval of Travel Expense Associated with the School Board Members' and
Superintendent Breslin's Attendance at the FSBA-FADSS Annual Joint Conference, at the Grand Hyatt Tampa Bay, FL November 31-December 4, 2026 Not to Exceed
$6,700.00 (General Fund). It was noted that after this one in Tampa, these meetings will be held in Orlando. Approved 5-0.
Updates
Instruction. Mr. Derek Jensen indicated Progress Monitoring 2 (PM2) will begin after Thanksgiving with results available after winter break to support learning. The Children’s Movement of Florida awarded Soar in 4 a $500 grant. One hundred elementary teams participated in the catapult competition for distance and accuracy at Bayshore High School. Parrish Community High School’s female Raiders placed first in their district and will advance to state. The Advanced Learning Expo was held at MTC on October 28 with 215 families participating. Mr. Jensen acknowledged National School Psychology week and he thanked the district’s psychologists. Middle schools finished their inaugural golf season with Mona Jain’s boys’ and girls’ teams finishing in first and Nolan’s teams as runners up. A Buffalo Creek Middle School student drummer was the only student to make the All-State Middle School Jazz band. Mr. Jensen noted that high schools were conducting music expos to introduce elementary and middle school students to their music programs. JROTC and high school bands are participating in Veteran’s Day events. High school swimming, cross country and golf teams are in their post season play. Braden River, Manatee, and Palmetto high school football teams are in post season play with Bayshore High School playing in a post season invitational. He thanked Ms. Spray and Mr. Tatem for their support and tough questions asked to strive for excellence.
Operations. Mr. Willie Clark announced a January 14, 2027, Job Fair for operations and a virtual job fair for teachers and paraprofessionals on November 17, 2026. He reminded employees to check their benefit enrollment verifications for accuracy. New benefits begin January 1, 2027. Next week Food and Nutrition Services will begin their USDA school meals audit which takes about 3 months to complete and is done every 4 years. Instructional Technology is completing audio enhancement in classrooms at three schools. The Transportation Department received four of the eleven 77 passenger busses ordered. The 30-seat mini-busses should arrive by mid-December, 2026. Last week the bus and auto technicians were recognized with a lunch. Mr. Tatem asked about open positions in mechanics and the response was that there are only 3 vacancies.
Legal. Mr. Dye said he will bring to the board soon for final review and approval the 50-year lease on One Stop portable housing to be followed by a long process or planning and site development. Mr. Dye said he has been in contact with the two newly elected board members for pre-board counsel and pitfalls regarding the Sunshine Law. He expressed appreciation to Board Members for taking their time to evaluate him. Mr. Dye indicated he thought his marks were pretty good but he always hated report cards but thought his parents would be proud of this one. He said it was bitter sweet to see board members rotating off the board and that both were engaged and asked good questions.
Superintendent. Dr. Breslin also said she was sure Mr. Dye’s report card was a good one. She thanked the board for the approval of the consent items. She thanked Rachel Sellers and her team for the clean audit. She announced that Dr. Halpin is going to partner with Easter Seals and will put in a Soar in 4 lab there. She thanked Mr. Zickafoose for coming and recognizing Dr. Hyer as she retires. She added that Dr. Hyer has a wealth of knowledge about charters and that charter schools will be represented on the interview team to identify her replacement. Dr. Breslin agreed the Bernie’s Book’s event was a great experience at Bashaw Elementary yesterday. She noted that Veteran’s Elementary ran a very good Veteran’s program yesterday. As Mr. Tatem is leaving the Board she said she knows his voice will be missed and that he has made a huge impact. Dr. Breslin presented him with a journal that included notes from district staff. She noted that Ms. Spray has always wanted everything to be financially sound and expressed appreciation to Ms. Spray for listening to the teachers and being hard working and fierce advocate for children. Dr. Breslin presented Ms. Spray with the gavel she used as Chair.
Board Comments
Ms. Felton reported that she represented the Board at Manatee County Stand-down for Veterans this week. She also attended the job fair. She also witnessed the students demonstrating their catapults. She acknowledged that she has sat across from Mr. Tatem for two years, remarking that sometimes they were “cranky” with each other, but most times not. She thanked him for his service on the board and in the military. She said they found common ground. Ms. Felton said Ms. Spray helped her find her feet as a new board member and appreciated her running a tight ship at the meetings.
Mr. Kennedy addressed Captain Gruters remarking that he is certainly an American hero and thanked Mr. Tatem for bringing him. He opined that this board has functioned at a high level since Mr. Tatem and Ms. Spray arrived four years ago. He remarked that even among diversity of opinions, the conversations have always remained civil. He wished Mr. Tatem well with his dissertation. He told Ms. Spray that she has grown so much, and has been so focused on the staff and students, and not her personal agenda. He told her, “I know this will not be your last time in a public servant seat.”
Mr. Choate said the Veterans Elementary presentation was well done and all branches’ flags were flown from the flag poles. He said the Bernie’s Books at Bashaw was great to see and that the school has changed since he was a kindergartner there. He said watching the children’s reaction was so special. Mr. Choate thanked Captain Gruters for his awesome presentation. He noted that Mr. Tatem and Ms. Spray have served and run at the same time as he did and that it will be weird not to have them there. He appreciated what Mr. Tatem brought to the board and enjoyed getting more of his story and that Mr. Tatem’s awareness of student safety is very special. He praised Ms. Spray’s great year as Chair. He said he felt “all three of us served well together and it has always been professional.” He noted that Ms. Spray brought the Board’s awareness to the foster care system and it may have been overlooked more than it should have been.
Mr. Tatem indicated he was speaking for the last time. He said he thought Veteran’s Day was well celebrated yesterday and thanked Captain Gruters for his presentation today. Unlike General MacArthur’s last speech where he said his last thoughts were of the corps, Mr. Tatem said his last thoughts will not be of the school board. However, he admired Mr. Jefferson’s tombstone that does not note he was President but was author of the Declaration of Independence, author of Declaration of Rights for Virginia, and founder of the Univ of Virginia. He said he won’t miss the bureaucracy of the schools (like the Air Force) but will miss the people. He said, we have been boring and that is a good thing; we are professional. It is good we don’t have drama. He hopes that continues. He appreciated working with Dr. Breslin. He ended with a benediction. And then –“you can never have too much cowbell’ as he brought out a white cowbell and rang it.
Ms. Spray reminisced that this Board has had some heavy lifts including rezoning, hiring a new superintendent, building five different schools, Board classes completed, that she read 90% of all the agenda materials, with sticky notes to ask questions during briefings. She said, “When you do public service that is what you do.” She agreed the ceremony at Veterans Elementary was very moving and that she had pushed to have it done. Ms. Spray said that we are still under the Sunshine until Tuesday but she will have a lot to say to each of the Board Members after that date. She said she hopes she represented District 2 well. She recognized the partnerships that were built with the cities of Palmetto and Bradenton. She acknowledged she lost a grandson on the same day as the election. Ms. Spray said the election was not the real loss; it was the loss of her grandson and she expressed appreciation for all the support given to her.
Adjournment: 12:16 p.m.
While the stories presented by Mrs. Kahn about the Holocaust last month and by Captain Gruters about his military service were exceptional, we recommend the Board Chair provide a time limit on all future presentations.
When the topics of Internal Accounts and the Citizen Financial Audit Committee Charter, Board comments were observed to be vague and non-specific.
LWV Note: We appreciate both Mr. Tatem and Ms. Spray’s service on the School Board of the Manatee School District. We recognize the work and sacrifices that are made when holding a public office
Comments
No comments on this item
Only paid subscribers can comment
Please log in to comment by clicking here.