Log in Subscribe

County to Apply for Rezone of Downtown Central Library Property

Posted
BRADENTON – In a regular meeting Tuesday, the Manatee County Commission voted 5-2 to move forward with an application for rezoning the county's central library property. The site is under the jurisdiction of the City of Bradenton. While the motion successfully passed the board, there were differences of opinion on the appropriate process among members.

Board members had previously discussed the possibility of relocating the library in order to get the valuable riverfront property on the tax rolls. Commissioner Kevin Van Ostenbridge had requested to add the motion to Tuesday’s consent agenda, but Commissioner Carol Whitmore requested to pull the item for discussion before a vote could be taken.

The arguments for moving the library are at least two-fold. In addition to the potential for tax revenue if owned by an entity other than local government, utilizing the lot along the waterfront for future housing, restaurants, or retail would also be of benefit to downtown Bradenton’s revitalization, which includes the city's plans to relocate City Hall, which sits just east of the library.

Most recently, the topic arose during a joint meeting held with the Manatee County Commission and the Bradenton City Council late last month. Commissioners George Kruse and Van Ostenbridge have been in public agreement that exploring a sell-off and relocation of the central library could, in conjunction with city hall, open an opportunity to maximize the potential of the riverfront along Barcarrota Avenue.

On Tuesday, Van Ostenbridge explained to his colleagues that his addition of the motion to the consent agenda was, in his mind, only a first step in accessing the full potential of the property. Van Ostenbridge’s perspective was that it would be necessary first to know whether the property would be granted a rezone from T5 to T6 by the city–expanding the property’s approved use to include the increased height and density–before the county could even assess the return value in potentially selling the property at all.

"To be clear," Van Ostenbridge told the board, "all I am asking for is to get the rezone to the maximum potential."

Van Ostenbridge shared that at some point in the future he did intend to bring forward to the board a proposal to consider listing the property for sale. He explained that a rezoning would afford the board necessary data concerning the property’s true potential value and use–something the board would need to know for the sake of determining whether a relocation of the library and sale of the property would make sense financially.

Van Ostenbridge suggested that post-rezone (assuming it is approved by the city), an appraisal could provide the board with the information it would need to consider whether the sale of the property would support the construction of a new library elsewhere in the county. He said that a better location for a new, state-of-the-art, municipal center might include relocation to an unserved community within the county.

Commissioner Carol Whitmore supported the possibility of looking into options for relocating the library, but initially in Tuesday’s discussion, she shared some concerns about the motion coming before the board without an appropriate process. Whitmore cited the item having been added to the administrator’s consent agenda, rather than affording the public the opportunity to participate in the discussion before moving forward with an application for a rezone.

Whitmore also questioned what the expense of applying for the rezoning would be, and how such a cost would be paid.

However, Commissioner George Kruse–who participated in the discussion remotely–agreed with Van Ostenbridge that applying for a rezone does not negate the board’s ability for future work sessions and public discussion.

"I’m fully in support of this rezone," offered Kruse.

Kruse reminded his colleagues that he has been a consistent advocate for the county’s library system and that he did not view a potential rezoning application as a threat to the county’s central library or library system.

"I would never approve or vote for anything that sold the central library without a plan in place to rebuild it," Kruse said.

However, Commissioner Misty Servia, a certified planner with decades of experience, seemed to view the proposed motion as more of a cart before the horse approach. Servia explained that a property need not be rezoned to be listed for sale, and that the sale of such a property could be contingent on the subsequent approval of an upzone.

Servia suggested there are other issues facing the county that resources should be more immediately expended on, rather than utilizing resources and potential funds to rezone a property before there is a discussion about whether, or where, the county would relocate the library.

"I just don’t want to waste time, energy, or resources," Servia said. "I just don’t think this is the appropriate step at this time."

Servia stated that it was her professional opinion that the most efficient process for considering a property’s potential value, resale, and rezoning, is to first list the property for sale and generate interest. She argued that spending time, money, and resources on a rezone–for which there is no guaranteed approval–did not make business sense.

"I think that this would be starting in the middle of a potential process," Servia explained, "but we need to start at the beginning of the process."

Servia said rezoning a property to "predict the market," from her professional experience, is not typical of how business is conducted.

Commissioner Reggie Bellamy agreed with some of the comments shared by Whitmore and Servia. He also expressed concern with the order in which the process was being suggested. Bellamy advocated for the need to hold public hearings to afford public participation and feedback on the potential sale and relocation of the library.

While Bellamy seemed pleased to hear a suggestion from Van Ostenbridge to consider the library’s relocation to an underserved community, potentially in Bellamy’s district 2, he also stated his position that for his support of Van Ostenbridge’s motion, it would require there be pre-identified land, funding, and a legal commitment.

Commissioners Baugh and Satcher leaned toward agreement on arguments and points raised by fellow Commissioners Van Ostenbrdge and Kruse. They agreed that applying for a rezoning does little more than potentially maximize the property’s future use and resale, should the rezoning be granted.

Van Ostenbridge assured the board that rezoning does not take the place of future public discussions nor the required research for an alternative location for the library, or the expense to relocate it.

Ultimately, Whitmore was assured by what her colleagues offered during the discussion.

"We are not committing to anything, but then we will know the value of that property if we decide to move it," Whitmore added. "And I support moving it as a central library to somewhere else."

In the end, the motion passed 5-2 with commissioners Servia and Bellamy dissenting, and county staff will be directed to begin the process and application for a rezone. The commission mutually agreed that future work sessions and public discussions will come sometime after the commission learns the outcome of the rezone application.

To replay the related portion of Tuesday's meeting and board discussion, click the video below.




Comments

No comments on this item

Only paid subscribers can comment
Please log in to comment by clicking here.